
How a CTI ATC-105 Cooling Tower Performance Test Is Done: Procedure, Instruments, Tolerance
This is the how-to: what happens, in order, when a cooling tower is performance tested to the CTI ATC-105 method. If you want a test carried out rather than explained, see our cooling tower performance testing service in Thailand.
What the test answers
A performance test answers one question: does the tower cool as much water as its design curves say it should? CTI ATC-105 — the Acceptance Test Code for Water Cooling Towers, published by the Cooling Technology Institute (CTI) — expresses the answer as capability: the circulating water flow the tower handles at design fan power, divided by the flow the manufacturer’s performance curves predict for the measured conditions. 100% means the tower does what its curves say. Because the curves translate the test-day weather and load to design conditions, the test does not need the exact design day.
The temperatures behind that number are simple:
- Range — the hot-water temperature minus the cold-water temperature across the tower.
- Approach — the cold-water temperature minus the entering wet-bulb temperature; how close the tower gets to the theoretical limit set by ambient air.
Airflow (read from fan power) and water distribution decide whether the tower can hold its Range and Approach, which is why they are recorded alongside the temperatures.
Conditions before the test starts
The code does not allow a test on any day the plant happens to be running. In summary:
- Stable operation. Each measured parameter may only drift within set limits during the test period, so the tower and the heat source are held steady before data collection starts.
- Weather close to design. An acceptance test must be run with the wet-bulb temperature within 15 °F (about 8 °C) of the design value.
- Fan power close to design. The 2019 edition allows fan motor power to deviate from design by up to 15%, which corresponds to roughly a 5% change in airflow.
- A prepared tower. Water flow balanced, fans pitched so the motor power is within the code limits, and the tower in a condition CTI’s preparation guidance accepts.
Instruments and where they go
| Measurement | How it is taken |
|---|---|
| Wet-bulb (and dry-bulb) temperature | Calibrated sensors in mechanically aspirated psychrometers, placed within about 1.5 m of the air inlets |
| Cold-water temperature | Typically downstream of the pumps, where the water is well mixed; an array of submersible sensors in the outfall or flume when that is not possible |
| Hot-water temperature | One location near the tower is usually enough; flow-weighted readings when separate return lines are not well mixed |
| Water flow | Most often a calibrated pitot tube at the tower inlet, traversed across two perpendicular diameters; each flow measurement takes from 1 to 4 hours depending on pipe size and access |
| Fan motor power | Measured at the motor control centre with a calibrated meter, corrected for the voltage loss to the motor |
The test, step by step
- Install calibrated instruments for wet-bulb and dry-bulb temperature, water flow, hot and cold water temperature, and fan power.
- Hold the tower steady and collect data over a stable operating period, checking each parameter against the stability limits as the data arrives.
- Analyse the data with the CTI Toolkit or equivalent thermal modelling software, correcting to design conditions with the manufacturer’s performance curves.
- Issue a report stating the measured conditions, the comparison basis, the result and any limitations.
Testing does not need the tower to stop. A single-cell test typically needs 4–8 hours of on-site data collection and a multi-cell tower 1–2 days. See CTI ATC-105 explained for how Synergy applies the code.
Test tolerance is not test uncertainty
Two terms are easy to mix up, and the difference decides whether a test is “passed”:
- Tolerance is a permitted shortfall written into the purchase contract. If the contract allows a 3.2% tolerance, a tower tested at 97% of its guarantee is contractually accepted. The code asks for the tolerance to be stated in the contract even if its value is zero.
- Uncertainty is an estimate of the possible error in the test result itself, caused by measurement error. ATC-105 does not require an uncertainty analysis, unlike ASME PTC 23, but its Appendix U gives a method for one, consistent with ASME PTC 19.5 and a 95% confidence interval.
Uncertainty depends on the tower, the weather on the day and the piping at the flow measurement point, so it is not a fixed number for a given tower. For how the manufacturer’s curves tie a capability figure to a tower, read cooling tower capability explained.
Who can run which kind of test
A contractual ATC-105 acceptance test is performed by a CTI-licensed test agent. A field test that follows the same method to find out how an operating tower is doing today is a different job: it gives a baseline, not a certificate.
At Synergy Services, our engineers are trained in CTI test procedures and have conducted performance evaluations on cooling towers serving Thailand’s petrochemical, sugar, cement, and power generation industries. Our 12-cell baseline assessment at a Kanchanaburi biofuel site is one published example.
What to do with the result
A gap between measured and design performance points the next step. Degraded fill, fouled nozzles and damaged fan blades call for parts replacement; a gap that parts cannot close is the data behind a cooling tower upgrade or reconstruction.
Good moments to test: after any major maintenance or overhaul; when process temperatures are higher than expected; before and after a fill replacement to verify the improvement; and as part of an annual energy audit.
Get a performance test for your plant
Synergy Services provides cooling tower performance testing across Thailand, including the Eastern Seaboard, Chonburi, Rayong, and the Isan region. See the cooling tower performance testing service for scope, or contact our team to schedule an assessment.
Sources
- CTI ATC-105 — Acceptance Test Code for Water Cooling Towers — the Cooling Technology Institute’s acceptance test code this article’s procedure follows.
- Review of New 2019 CTI ATC 105 Acceptance Test Code for Cooling Towers — D. Wheeler and K. Hennon, CleanAir Engineering; the source for the test conditions, instrument placement, tolerance and uncertainty points above.
Need cooling tower services in Thailand?
Contact Synergy Services for expert cooling tower solutions in Thailand.
Contact our team
